7 Brand Positioning Mistakes to Avoid (and How to Fix Them)

Weak brand positioning rarely happens overnight. Instead, it often starts with small decisions that seem harmless.

You copy what works for competitors. You try to serve every customer. You add more services to increase revenue. You assume that having a good product is enough to win customers.

However, these decisions can slowly weaken your brand. Eventually, customers struggle to understand what makes your business different.

So, what are the most common brand positioning mistakes? More importantly, how can you avoid them?

In this guide, we explore seven mistakes that weaken brand positioning. We also explain why they happen and how to fix them. Our discussion draws on insights from Jack Trout, Laura Ries and Alice Tybout.

Key Takeaways

  • Most brand positioning mistakes happen when a business fails to define who it serves and why customers should choose it.
  • The seven common mistakes include copying competitors, targeting everyone, stretching your brand and making claims without proof.
  • A strong position starts with clear choices. Spending more on marketing will not fix a weak position.
  • Repositioning an established brand takes time and carries risks. Therefore, get your positioning right before investing heavily in design and advertising.

What Are the 7 Most Common Brand Positioning Mistakes?

The most common brand positioning mistakes make it difficult for customers to understand what a business offers and why it is different.

For example, some businesses copy their competitors. Others try to serve everyone or make promises they cannot prove.

Although these mistakes look different, they share one problem. They make a brand less distinctive.

Here are seven mistakes every business should avoid:

  1. Copying competitors: Find out what other brands already claim. Then choose a different position.
  2. Owning a rival’s idea: Choose a benefit that competitors have not already established in customers’ minds.
  3. Trying to serve everyone: Focus on one audience and one customer need in each positioning statement.
  4. Stretching your brand: Avoid adding services that weaken what your brand represents.
  5. Being vague about your offer: Explain what you sell in simple, clear language.
  6. Making claims without proof: Support your promises with evidence.
  7. Assuming the truth will win: Understand how customers see your brand, not just how you describe it.

Are you building a brand position from scratch? If so, start with our brand positioning framework. [VERIFY URL]

Now, let’s look at each mistake and how you can avoid it.

1. Copying Competitors Instead of Finding Your Difference

Copying competitors is a major brand positioning mistake. Why? Because customers struggle to choose between businesses that make the same promises.

Think about it. If every business claims to offer quality, excellent service and affordable prices, what makes one different from another?

Jack Trout discusses this problem in 9 Major Marketing Mistakes. He describes the me-too approach as a poor strategy for businesses entering markets with established competitors.

He also argues that two companies cannot own the same idea in a buyer’s mind.

Laura Ries makes a similar point in her Entrepreneur article on branding mistakes. She explains that when every competitor follows the same trends, their products and messages eventually become similar.

Instead, she encourages businesses to study their competitors and find a different way to stand out.

Trout uses Volvo and safety to illustrate this idea. Other car manufacturers also promoted safety. However, Volvo became strongly associated with that benefit in buyers’ minds.

As a result, another carmaker trying to own the same idea would face a difficult challenge.

Why Copying Competitors Makes Your Brand Less Distinctive

Consider a hypothetical digital agency. It describes itself as a provider of “creative, results-driven digital solutions.”

The problem is simple. Almost every agency could make the same claim. Consequently, potential clients see little difference between their options. They may then choose based on price alone.

When businesses repeat the same claims, they give customers fewer reasons to choose one over another. A brand needs a distinct benefit that customers can recognise and remember.

How to Find a Different Position

Start by studying your competitors.

List the three claims they use most often in their marketing. Next, identify what makes your business different from those claims.

Do not simply replace their words with similar phrases. Instead, find a benefit that matters to your audience and that your business can prove.

Your goal is not to sound like the best version of your competitors. It is to give customers a different reason to choose you.

2. Trying to Serve Everyone

Trying to serve everyone can weaken your brand positioning. This is because a message designed for everybody may not connect strongly with anyone.

A specialist with a clear promise often appears more relevant to the right customer. On the other hand, a brand that offers everything may struggle to communicate what it does best.

Jack Trout identifies the everything-for-everybody approach as a major marketing mistake. He also links it to line extension.

Line extension happens when a business uses an established brand name to sell more products or services. However, this can make the original brand meaning less clear.

Trout quotes a manager who explains the idea this way:

“I’d rather be strong somewhere than weak everywhere.”

Laura Ries shares a similar view. She advises businesses to resist unnecessary expansion when a brand begins to gain traction. Apart from geographic expansion, narrowing the brand’s focus may be a better choice.

Alice Tybout also discusses the “does it all” position in her Kellogg on Branding chapter on brand positioning.

This approach presents a brand as a complete solution. However, customers who want one specific benefit may choose a competitor that focuses on delivering that benefit.

Also, broad claims can be difficult for customers to believe.

Why Expanding Your Offer Can Weaken Your Brand

Consider a hypothetical IT company that starts by offering network support.

Over time, it adds CCTV installation, solar installation and website design. Each new service looks like another way to increase revenue.

However, the business gradually loses its identity. Customers no longer know what it does best. Meanwhile, each service puts the company in competition with specialist providers.

This is one of the risks of stretching a brand too far. The business may gain more services, but customers can lose a clear understanding of what the brand represents.

How to Choose a Clearer Audience

Choose one primary audience and one customer need for each positioning statement.

If your business serves two different audiences, write separate statements for each one. This allows you to communicate relevant benefits without confusing your customers.

Remember, growth does not always mean offering more services. Sometimes, the better opportunity is to become the preferred choice in one clearly defined market.

Here is how to write a positioning statement for each audience.

3. Being Vague About What You Sell

Customers cannot choose a brand they do not understand. Therefore, being vague about your offer can weaken your positioning.

Before someone chooses your business, they need to understand two things. First, what do you offer? Second, why should they care?

Jack Trout argues that many businesses struggle to explain what they sell. He also points out that simple, powerful explanations often support major marketing successes.

Laura Ries makes a similar point. She encourages teams to describe their category and difference in just two or three words.

This sounds easy. However, many businesses struggle to do it.

If your team needs an entire paragraph to explain what makes your business different, customers may struggle to remember it.

For example, compare these two descriptions:

  • “We provide innovative, integrated solutions that empower businesses to achieve sustainable growth.”
  • “We provide payroll software for small private schools.”

The first statement sounds impressive. However, it does not clearly explain what the business sells.

The second statement gives customers a much clearer idea of the offer.

How to Make Your Brand Positioning Clearer

Start with a simple sentence:

We are a [category] for [target audience].

Next, explain what makes your offer different.

If your description could apply to almost every competitor, your positioning may still be too broad.

Finally, test your explanation with someone outside your business. Can they repeat what you offer after hearing it once?

If not, simplify your message. Clear communication should always come before clever wording.

4. Making Claims Without Proof and Ignoring Customer Perception

Another common brand positioning mistake is making promises without evidence.

Your business may believe it offers the best product or service in its category. However, customers need a reason to believe that claim.

Jack Trout explains this through his argument that marketing is a battle of perceptions, not facts. Similarly, Alice Tybout stresses the importance of giving customers a concrete reason to believe a brand’s promise.

Trout includes the belief that “truth will win out” among the major marketing mistakes.

His argument is straightforward. Businesses often research their products, confirm that they offer something valuable and expect customers to recognise that value.

Unfortunately, the market does not work that way.

Customers make decisions based on what they understand and believe about a brand. Therefore, having a good product does not automatically guarantee a strong market position.

Why Your Brand Needs Proof

Tybout explains that a reason to believe should provide concrete evidence for the benefit a brand promises.

However, she also warns that competitors can easily copy proof based only on product features.

This means businesses need to think carefully about the evidence behind their claims. A promise becomes more convincing when customers can see why they should believe it.

What the Aleve Example Teaches About Customer Perception

Tybout’s discussion of Aleve provides a useful example.

Aleve was initially positioned broadly as a convenient pain reliever. However, its twelve-hour dosing led some buyers to associate it with slow action rather than convenience.

The brand was later repositioned around arthritis pain. In this context, less frequent dosing became a meaningful reason to believe in its benefit.

This example highlights an important lesson. A benefit may be valuable, but customers must understand it in the right way.

How to Align Your Claims With Customer Perception

Start by gathering evidence before making claims about your business.

You can use customer results, testimonials, product features, professional credentials or a distinctive process to support your promises.

Next, find out how customers actually perceive your brand.

Ask existing customers what they associate with your business. Also, find out why they chose you and what they believe makes you different.

If their answers do not match your intended positioning, you may need to change your message.

Your positioning should reflect a benefit customers understand and have a reason to believe.

5. How to Fix Weak Brand Positioning

Fixing weak brand positioning starts with understanding your audience, competitors, benefits and proof.

Instead of immediately changing your logo or redesigning your website, examine what your brand currently communicates.

A new campaign cannot solve a positioning problem if customers still do not understand what makes your business different.

However, changing an established brand’s position requires careful planning.

Tybout describes repositioning an established brand as a strategy of last resort. This is because it can alienate existing customers, confuse buyers and require considerable time and money.

She also recognises that smaller adjustments may sometimes be necessary, as the Aleve example demonstrates.

Therefore, before making major changes, conduct a simple brand positioning audit.

A Simple Brand Positioning Audit

You can start with three practical steps.

Step 1: Review your marketing messages.

Visit your website and read your homepage, service descriptions and other important marketing materials.

Underline every claim that your competitors also make. These claims may show that your brand is not communicating a clear difference.

Step 2: Identify claims you cannot prove.

Review the promises your business makes to customers.

Mark every claim that lacks supporting evidence. Then identify what proof you need before continuing to use it.

Step 3: Ask customers how they see your brand.

Speak to at least three existing customers.

Ask them to describe your business in their own words. Find out why they chose you and what they believe makes you different.

Finally, compare their answers with the message your business currently communicates.

The difference between these two perspectives can reveal important positioning problems.

Who Can Help You Fix Your Brand Positioning?

Fixing your brand positioning takes more than changing a few words on your website. It requires a clear understanding of your market, audience and competitive advantage.

This is where strategic support can help.

Crystal Mediatech is a content marketing and brand positioning agency in Nigeria. We help businesses identify weaknesses in their positioning and communicate their value more clearly.

Our process starts with strategy. We examine your audience, competitors, market position and existing communication. Then, we develop a clearer direction for your brand.

After that, we translate the strategy into content that helps customers understand and believe in your business.

We work with teams in Nigeria and remotely with businesses in other countries and continents.

Want to see how we combine brand positioning with content strategy? Read about our positioning and content services.

Not sure which brand positioning mistake is affecting your business?

Talk to us about building a clearer position for your brand.l help you identify where your positioning is falling short and what you can do to make it stronger.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Telegram

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Our Newsletter

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.